Lancome Artliner vs L’oreal Super Linear Black Lacquer

Here is a comparison of liquid eye liners. Its the battle between Lancome Artliner and L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer. I wanted to compare both of this eye liners after I have noticed that their applicators are very similar.  I have been using Lancome Artliner for months and L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer for 2 weeks. Let’s begin with their description.

Emphasize your eyes with this easy-to-handle, liquid pen featuring a uniquely shaped foam tip that lets you line, shape and define eyes to create any look you like. Rich, deep, luminous pigments offer the most intense, dramatic color. Glides on smoothly without scratching, tugging or skipping and lasts all day. – Lancome Artliner

 

L’Oréal Paris Superliner in Black Lacquer is a special sponge tipped pen, great for applying fine lines of eyeliner or thick sultry flicks! It automatically regulates the right amount of liner for a neat, even outline and long lasting intense colour. – L’Oreal

 

Lancome Artliner vs L'oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer - Applicator

Looking at both eye liner’s applicator on side by side, they look really similar. Lancome Artliner applicator is made of  foam and L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer is made of special sponge, which I reckon both may be the same material because they feel the same and the flexibility is the same. L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer’s applicator does physically looked much flimsy. Both are should be shaken before use.

Lancome Artliner vs L'oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer - Swatch

Lancome Artliner seems to be less pigmented and slightly streaky compared to L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer. Both are in black with slight gloss finish to it. L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer has that typical eye liner scent, much more stronger than Lancome Artliner but its not a big issue.

Lancome Artliner vs L'oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer - Before & After

Lancome Artliner

  • 8:54AM – Freshly applied, there’s a patch without eye liner. I believe my lash curler is the cause of it.
  • 3:45PM – Still remains the same as how it looks like when freshly applied.
  • 6:26PM – The winged out is slightly smudged.

L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer

  • 8:45AM – Freshly applied
  • 3:45PM – Looking still as good as freshly applied
  • 6:26PM – The eye liner still looking great without smudging

Verdict?

I love both eye liner because its easy to use but apparently Lancome Artliner smudges. During application, I need to dip into the tube more often for L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer because it dries easily once applied. When removing L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer, it comes of a strip like lash glue which is good that is doesn’t leave residue behind. Lancome Artliner is priced at MYR95 and I have purchased L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer MYR28.70 (retail price at MYR35.90). The best worth eye liner between two of these will be L’oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer because its purse friendly, last up to more than 10 hours, easy to remove and apply.

 

xoxo,
Traclyn Yeoh
Print Friendly

4 Comments

    • Before I tried L’oreal, I thought Lancome Artliner is one of the best liquid eye liner that I had. Now, its totally different!

    • The Loreal eye liner comes off a strip but it doesn’t stick as tacky as eye lash glue. I’m a fan of Kate liquid eyeliner!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *