Review: Faking That Undetectable Flaw Didn’t Work For Me With Benefit Fake Up Crease-Control Hydrating Concealer

As much as I remember using stick concealer, they could be drying or cakey. I can’t deny that they are easy to use as you could just glide on wherever you want to conceal, blend, set and you’re ready to go. At most time, stick concealers are not recommended to be applied around the eye area since there is a chance on drying up the skin on the area and users are unlikely to risk their skin for so. Normally, it is recommended to use liquid concealer as they are much versatile for the delicate  area such as under-eye. There is one concealer to beat all that risk which is Benefit Fake Up Crease-Control Hydrating Concealer.

Benefit Fake Up Crease-Control Hydrating Concealer

‘Cover-up goes incognito! This hydrating crease-control concealer – with Vitamin E & apple seed extract – hides dark circles & diffuses fine lines for a silky smooth, ultra-natural look. Available in three shades, it’s proven to keep skin hydrated for 6 hours!* *Instrumental test
Results too good to conceal!

  • 100% said fakeup hydrates skin*
  • 100% said fakeup feels comfortable on skin*
  • 100% said the texture feels silky*
  • 94% said the effect is long-lasting*
  • 94% said fakeup doesn’t run*
  • 97% said the formula is lightweight*
  • 91% said fakeup conceals dark circles*
  • 91% saw a natural appearance*
  • 97% said the packaging makes it easy to use*

*Results observed in a consumer panel survey.’ – Benefit

Their ad is very interesting, it is a must watch and it’s not like your typical makeup ads. They come in three shades and the shade that I have is the lightest shade of all which is ‘fair’ and I’m a little worried that it may turn out to be too fair for my skin tone.

Benefit Fake Up Crease-Control Hydrating Concealer - Info

This was the manual that was included with the concealer, sharing where are the beneficial ingredients are contained and tips on where we could use it. It never came across my mind that it can be used on eye area and it seems like a promising concealer especially when it claims to control on creasing of this concealer. We will look upon it on my lasting test.

Benefit Fake Up Crease-Control Hydrating Concealer - Swatch

The concealer comes in a twist up metal case, embossed with the word ‘fake up’ with twirl patterns. It looks really similar to a lipstick packaging. Identical to the structure of the concealer and hydrator, you could see the layer of hydrator that goes along at the sides of the concealer seems like balm texture in the swatch. It blends easily as the texture feels creamy, along with that now I’m worried if the texture could be too rich.

Benefit Fake Up Crease-Control Hydrating Concealer - How To Use

Here is a mini tutorial on how I use the concealer. It glides on easily and I went on a trigger-happy mode concealing all around my face.

Benefit Fake Up Crease-Control Hydrating Concealer - Before and After

I was right about the shade of concealer, it was too fair for me. When I use it for the first time, I only conceal on my under-eye and it was very contrasting between my cheek area. Therefore, I had to use it all around my face to keep everything well balanced and even.  The coverage is sheer to medium as the redness on my under-eye and other part of my face is still seeping through. It was tricky to conceal breakouts even though I have tried to double conceal.

Benefit Fake Up Crease-Control Hydrating Concealer - Lasting After 9 Hours

Here comes the lasting test of the day. I have had the concealer for more than 9 hours and what I like about it is that it didn’t oxidize as much. However, the concealer doesn’t have any oil controlling property and loses its coverage as you may compare the obvious redness at the sides of my nose.

Benefit Fake Up Crease-Control Hydrating Concealer - Eyes

Particularly, this concealer claims that it controls creasing, I was very skeptical if it does especially with the tropical weather in Malaysia.  Both may look almost the same but I do have fine lines on my under eye and if you look carefully, there is some creasing happening on those fine lines. If this doesn’t convince you, let’s have a look on the next photo.

Benefit Fake Up Crease-Control Hydrating Concealer - Eye Lid

Could you see the evident line on my eyelid at 6:50PM? The line proofs that this concealer is not as crease-control as it claims. I would say this concealer may not be suitable for you if you have oily eye lid like I do.

Ingredients: Ricinus Communis (Castor) Seed Oil, C12-15 Alkyl Benzoate, Polyethylene, Caprylic/capric Triglyceride, Ethyhexyl Palmite, Cetearyl Isononanoate, Nylon-12, Silica, Phenoxyethanol, Caprylyl Glycol, Tocopheryl Acetate, Benzoic Acid, Ethylhexyl Myristate, Ethylhexyl Strearate, Hexydecanol, Butylene Glycol, Pyrus Malus (Apple) Fruit Extract, Brasicca Campesteris (Rapeseed) Steroils, BHT, Tocopheerol. [+/-: CI 19140 (Yellow 5, Yellow 5 Lake), CI 42090 (Blue 1 Lake), CI 77007, (Ultramarines), CI 77163 (Bismuth Oxychloride), CI 77491, CI 77492, CI 77499 (Iron Oxides), CI 77891 (Titanium Dioxide).

Above all…

I think this is more suitable for normal to dry skin types as it provides good hydration. As for me, I have combination skin which is not as suitable as this concealer doesn’t come with any oil controlling property. Even so, I like how it glide smoothly without tugging. Personally, I would prefer greater coverage and this coverage goes on more natural, it doesn’t build although I tried to double up the application. Do bare in mind that this concealer also contains silica, I personally do not have any problem with this ingredient.

Price: MYR90.00

Weight: 3.5g/0.12oz

Availability: Benefit counters or

For the latest update of Benefit Malaysia, remember to give them a like in their Facebook below!


  • Hydrating
  • Easy gliding smooth application
  • Natural coverage


  • Creases on fine line and double eyelid crease
  • Loses its coverage after 9 hours
  • Non-buildable coverage

My Rating: 4/5


~ ♦ ~

This concealer was one of the prize for Vanity Trove Malaysia Horrific Halloween, kindly refer disclaimer.

Traclyn Yeoh
Print Friendly, PDF & Email


A Malaysian beauty blogger expressing her views on beauty and life's other superficial aspects. Not to mention, beauty tutorials to appease the die-hard beauty junkies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.